I’m always down, always,” Fahy, a season 2 breakout star, told PEOPLE of her desire to return for another season

"I know that that would be something I would love to watch, too, if they didn't want to see Daphne again," Fahy says. "Because I love the show so much and there's so many amazing

Drop,' a clever Blumhouse thriller mostly set in a restaurant, is the beginning of a more ambitious phase for its star, who remembers struggling to break out.